Insight and inspiration in turbulent times.
resilience
By Kurt Cobb, originally published by Resource Insights
September 29, 2024
“Information wants to be free” has been the watchword of the so-called free culture movement which has manifested itself in such phenomena as the free and open source software community and as Creative Commons. (For those who don’t know, Creative Commons is a way to establish rights and authorship of creative works while also specifying how those works can be distributed and used by others in ways that are far less restrictive than traditional copyright—for instance, by allowing for varying levels of sharing, editing and incorporation in the works of others.)
It is in this tradition that following the sale of his web crawling company to Amazon for $250 million in 1999, Brewster Kahle increasingly devoted himself to his nonprofit startup, the Internet Archive, a project which became his full-time pursuit as of 2002 and remains so today. But today, the future of the Internet Archive is highly uncertain.
It is very likely that almost everyone reading this sentence has used the Internet Archive at some point to retrieve internet pages no longer available, to do research, or to archive internet pages for future reference.
Here’s how the Internet Archive describes its activities and holdings:
[W]e have 28+ years of web history accessible through the Wayback Machine and we work with 1,200+ library and other partners through our Archive-It program to identify important web pages.
As our web archive grew, so did our commitment to providing digital versions of other published works. Today our archive contains:
It’s an impressive collection and its very existence is being threatened by copyright holders who believe their rights have been violated and want substantial compensation. The struggle of those who create and copyright works of art, fiction, music, journalism, software and other forms of expression to control the promiscuous transmission of their work in the electronic age is not new. What is now at stake is whether a site that wishes to preserve electronic forms of those works can do so and whether it can survive lawsuits that not only threaten to prevent it from archiving such works, but also to bankrupt it so that is can no longer even provide access to works not covered by copyright protection.
The argument made by defenders of intellectual property is that without it, creative people would not produce works of art, fiction, music, journalism, software and so on. It is worth noting that copyright is a relatively recent phenomenon by historical standards, only coming into existence in the 1790s.
And, yet creative works have been undertaken by humans from the 30,000-year-old Chauvet Cave paintings in what today is southern France, to the marble statues of ancient Greece and Rome, to the paintings of Renaissance masters, to the works of Shakespeare, all without copyright law. (There were, of course, other methods by which the creators were supported.) And there is today the plethora of free content on the internet including free software, some of very high quality, for which the authors seek no compensation.
I am not saying there should be no copyright, only that the needs of the society which has educated and supported the creative person ought to be taken into account. I copyright my work on my blog. But I have never refused any reasonable request to repost my work when asked, and I have never complained to anyone who did so without permission if they gave me credit.
Having said all this, the Internet Archive and other online archives are in a precarious state for reasons other than copyright. We know of the Chauvet Cave paintings, the statues of Classical antiquity, Renaissance paintings and Shakespeare’s works because they were all rendered in physical mediums that were able to survive centuries and even millennia.
Of course, physical records of culture are by no means certain to survive. For example, the destruction of great libraries by war, looting, fire and official policy has a long history. But today all that needs to happen is for someone to pull the plug on our electronic archives either for legal reasons or for more cataclysmic reasons involving looming resource limits and climate change that undermine the stability of modern technical civilization so much that large-scale electronic archiving is no longer possible.
It is important to note that archives are an extension of human memory, and memory is the key to identity. Who we are today is almost entirely related to what we have done and who we’ve associated with in the past and what our ancestors did before us. To lose one’s memory as an individual, is to forget who one is. To lose it on a cultural level is to forget what nation or culture one belongs to.
The loss of the Internet Archive would be only a partial blow to our cultural memory as there will still be many other repositories of memory. But the comprehensive nature of this archive would be hard to reproduce in any form and its loss would vastly complicate trying to find information from the past that originated on the internet, but no longer resides there. For now, whether our civilization suffers a self-inflicted case of memory loss is in the hands of lawyers and judges. Why is it that I’m not feeling optimistic?
Kurt Cobb is a freelance writer and communications consultant who writes frequently about energy and environment. His work has appeared in The Christian Science Monitor, Common Dreams, Le Monde Diplomatique, Oilprice.com, OilVoice, TalkMarkets, Investing.com, Business Insider and many other places. He is the author of an oil-themed novel entitled Prelude and has a widely followed blog called Resource Insights. He is currently a fellow of the Arthur Morgan Institute for Community Solutions.
Tags: books
By Asher Miller, Resilience.org
Like so many people and organizations, we at Post Carbon Institute have been reflecting and recalibrating since November 5th. Wherever you fall on the political spectrum, Trump’s victory, along with his campaign pledges and cabinet nominations, should be an indication that the status quo is in the rearview mirror if not actually crumpled and smoking on the side of the road.
December 30, 2024
By Kurt Cobb, Resource Insights
Increasingly, it seems that the ongoing spread of bird flu among cattle and the possible evolution of a strain that can be transmitted between humans will be the biggest story of 2025. I hope I’m wrong.
December 29, 2024
By Nate Hagens, The Great Simplification
Today, Nate is joined by local organizer and activist Christian Sawyer, to discuss how he’s built a pro-social community in rural Arizona. Christian emphasizes the power of local collaboration and demonstrates how the cultivation of social capital builds resilience in the face of challenges, as well as creates better lives for those who live in the community.
December 23, 2024
Resilience is a program of Post Carbon Institute, a nonprofit organization dedicated to helping the world transition away from fossil fuels and build sustainable, resilient communities.
Reposting Policy | Privacy Policy
English 
Français