OpinionCynthia Astle | September 9, 2025
Dear President Trump, I have a hot flash for you: Religion never left America.
What’s more, those of us who’ve practiced our respective religions faithfully for generations aren’t about to let you force your white “Christian” nationalism down the throats of our children.
Your announcement about returning to prayer to schools is both ridiculous and alarming. It’s ridiculous because prayer never left schools; any student, teacher or administrator can pray anytime, anywhere. It’s alarming because the official imposition of one set of religious beliefs on a multifaith society violates everyone’s rights under the First Amendment to be free of government-established religion.
Cynthia Astle
Hate to beat a tired metaphor, but that’s what the Nazis did — turn their political beliefs into a cult, with Der Fuhrer as its god.
What you want isn’t religious freedom. You want everyone to conform to a corrupt idea of Christianity that will reinforce your authoritarian politics. That’s what the guidelines you’ll dictate to the Department of (Mis)Education are all about.
I can’t speak for any other believers, but I know I’m going to fight your latest abomination with all my might. I’m doing it for a boy named Michael.
Michael was one of my elementary school classmates. Every morning until I was in fifth grade, our class would recite the Pledge of Allegiance and the Lord’s Prayer. When we started to pray, Michael would leave the room and stand outside in the hall until we finished.
Michael was Jewish.
My 10-year-old self never understood why Michael stood in the hall. I thought maybe he was being punished. It wasn’t until the U.S. Supreme Court struck down school-sponsored prayer that I understood what an insult it was for Michael to be singled out because he and his family practiced a different religion than us Christian kids.
These days there are youngsters with more different religions in our public schools. Pew Research Center says there are 7.5 million Jews in America. There are about 3.3 million Hindus. There are 4 million Muslims. Both Pew and Public Religion Research Institute estimate Buddhists are about 1% of the U.S. population, somewhere between 1 million and 4 million people.
That’s not all. Professor Google’s AI assistant says, “Smaller numbers of people also identify with other faiths, including Sikhism, Daoism, Baha’i Faith, Zoroastrianism and other spiritual practices like Unitarian Universalism and Wicca.”
Are you going to go after them in the same way you’ve dispatched your personal military force to go after brown-skinned people who speak Spanish? Are you going to re-ignite “witch trials” to persecute Wiccans, or incite religions to fight one another the way your pal Modi has in India?
As a lifelong Christian, I don’t follow my neighbors’ non-Christian beliefs, but I demand they have the right to follow their consciences and not to have the government force one kind of religion upon them.
So, get ready, Mr. President. I’m not the only American believer who’s devoted to the constitutional right of freedom of religion, not least because religion isn’t under attack in the United States. The only one attacking freedom of religion in the United States is you and your far-right cohorts.
You don’t speak for me or for most of us faithful, and we’re not going to let you get away with what you’re planning.
So help us, God.
Cynthia B. Astle serves as editor of United Methodist Insight, an online journal she founded in 2011.
Related articles:
Trump says he’s bringing back prayer to schools
Anti-Christian bias’ task force focuses solely on grievances of evangelicals
Trump vows to ‘protect’ Christians in America
(123rf.com)
• Stuck in the Middle With You
• Highest Power: Church + State
• Non-Disclosure: The Silenced Stories of Kanakuk Kamps Survivors
• Change-making Conversations
BNG interview series on the state of faith, politics and resistance in our nation.
See also Greg’s series on Politics, Faith and Mission
Analysis
Analysis
News
Analysis
© 2025 Baptist News Global. All rights reserved.
Want to share a story? We hope you will! Read our republishing, terms of use and privacy policies here.
